top of page

How Should You Assess Client Retention Risk When Buying an Accounting Practice?

Sep 27
6 min read

Updated: Oct 24

GUEST AUTHOR | Blackhall & Co


Today’s guest post is by Blackhall & Co. Blackhall & Co helps buyers find businesses worth owning. Opinions expressed by guest authors are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Fairlane Finance.




Office Meeting Discussion

Client retention is best assessed by following both the relationships and the fees: who has stayed, what work has continued and what may change under your ownership.

Client Retention Risk deserves particular attention when buying an Australian accounting practice.


The vendor may know every major client personally, and the billing reports may show years of repeat work. That history is encouraging, but the acquisition introduces a change those relationships have not yet experienced.


At Stage 5, your task is to understand how the practice earned that loyalty and whether you can maintain it. A useful review brings together historical fee movements, the quality of client relationships and the transition you intend to deliver. The result should help you judge the practice under your ownership.



The short answer


  • Compare client numbers with fees retained from the same opening client groups.

  • Understand departures, reduced work and unresolved service concerns.

  • Identify relationships that depend on the vendor or particular staff.

  • Consider how your pricing, location and service plans may affect clients.

  • Connect the evidence to the handover, financial forecast and adviser-reviewed protections.



What evidence helps assess Client Retention Risk?


A client list is a starting point, rather than a retention assessment.


Some records may represent occasional assignments or inactive relationships. Others may belong to several entities controlled by one family or business owner. Without that context, the apparent size and stability of the client base can be misleading.



During due diligence, you can compare those summaries with billing reports, engagement records and documented correspondence. business.gov.au recommends examining financial records, operations and legal documents when reviewing an acquisition.


The most useful history follows comparable client groups through several periods. You should be able to see which relationships continued, which ended and which generated less work. Consistent periods and groupings matter: a change in billing software or entity names should not be mistaken for a departure.



Why can rising revenue conceal client losses?


A growing fee base can tell two stories at once. New clients and fee increases may lift total revenue while established relationships quietly fall away. As the buyer, you need to understand the performance of the clients already in the practice, because those are the relationships supporting the acquisition assumptions.


Client retention measures how many comparable opening client groups remain active. Fee retention considers how much revenue from that same group continues.


Neither measure explains everything on its own. Losing a small occasional client has a different financial effect from losing a longstanding business group with substantial annual fees.


A reduction in fees also needs an explanation. The client may have sold a business, brought bookkeeping in-house or completed a one-off project. Alternatively, they may be moving work to another adviser. Billing records, scope changes and the vendor's explanation should tell a reasonably consistent story.



What keeps the important relationships together?


Your earlier owner-dependence assessment may have identified clients who rely heavily on the vendor. Due diligence takes that observation further: you need to understand what the vendor does for them and how another person could earn their confidence.


For instance, a client may value a familiar senior accountant who answers questions promptly, while another expects direct access to the principal for difficult decisions. Those relationships need different handover arrangements. A general announcement of new ownership may be sufficient for neither.


The service history can reveal vulnerabilities that the retention figures miss. An overdue assignment, disputed invoice or unanswered complaint may leave a client dissatisfied even though they remain on the books. You should understand what happened, whether the matter has been resolved and what responsibility could fall to you.



How might your ownership plans change the experience?


Retention is partly about what you intend to change. Higher fees, a new office, remote meetings or different staff contacts may make commercial sense, but clients will experience them as changes to the service they know. Several changes arriving together can be harder to explain than a carefully staged transition.


For important relationships, you and the vendor should discuss practical continuity. The vendor might introduce you before a significant annual assignment, remain available for an agreed period or help explain a new contact arrangement.


Your team will also need the time and knowledge to deliver what clients have been promised.


This is where the handover becomes more than goodwill. If your plan depends on personal introductions or continued technical support, the proposed hours, responsibilities and availability need to be clear. The cost of that support belongs in your acquisition assumptions.



An illustrative retention review


Suppose 100 opening client groups generated $600,000 in annual fees. In the following comparable period, 95 remained and produced $550,000. Ten new groups added $70,000, taking total revenue to $620,000. These are hypothetical figures, not a market benchmark or forecast.


At first glance, rising revenue and 95% client retention look reassuring. Yet only about 91.7% of the opening group's fees continued.


The $50,000 reduction deserves attention: was it caused by the five departures, less work from continuing clients, or differences in billing timing?


The answer changes your response. A completed one-off assignment may simply require a forecast adjustment. Several departures following service problems may call for closer investigation and a stronger transition plan.


If further fees disappear after settlement, staffing, rent and software costs may not fall at the same pace.



What should be resolved before you proceed?


Your review should leave you with a clear view of the exposure and the proposed response. Rather than treating every concern as a reason to abandon the deal, you can distinguish matters requiring more evidence from those needing a commercial or legal solution.


  • Which significant relationships need introductions, and who will organise them?

  • Which service issues remain unresolved, and what will address them?

  • What support will the vendor provide during important work and billing periods?

  • Which unanswered questions affect the next decision or contractual deadline?

  • Do the findings change the price, cash-flow forecast or funding requirement?


Where retention payments or clawbacks form part of the transaction, your solicitor should review how they operate. The definition of retained fees, measurement period, exclusions, buyer obligations and dispute process all matter.


A payment adjustment can allocate some financial risk, but it does not keep a client or replace the disruption caused by their departure.


Any revised payment arrangement also needs to fit the vendor-finance and deferred-consideration structure. Your acquisition finance adviser should know when material findings change the assumptions previously presented.



Frequently asked questions


Does strong historical retention mean clients will stay?

It is encouraging evidence, but ownership creates a new event. The useful question is whether the relationships, service quality and continuity that supported retention will remain credible under your proposed operating model.


Should I measure client numbers or revenue?

Both. Client numbers show how relationships have changed, while comparable fees show the financial effect. Related entities should be grouped consistently, with new clients distinguished from the opening group so growth does not obscure losses.


Can I contact clients during due diligence?

Agree the process with the vendor and your solicitor first. OAIC guidance explains privacy considerations in business-sale due diligence. De-identified or aggregated records can help, and confidentiality arrangements alone should not be treated as permission to disclose client information.


Is there a safe retention percentage?

No universal percentage establishes that a purchase is sound. Its significance depends on the fees exposed, margins, concentration, costs and the transition arrangements. The explanation behind the figure matters as much as the figure itself.


Does loan approval verify client retention?

No. Lender assessment and buyer due diligence serve different purposes. You still need to assess the relationships, operating assumptions and risks you are prepared to accept.



Turn the findings into a decision


A strong retention review helps you understand what clients value and what maintaining that value will require. Where the evidence supports the handover, you can proceed with clearer assumptions. Where it does not, the missing answers need to remain visible until they receive a considered response.



Sources and further reading


Contributor disclaimer: This article is contributed by Blackhall & Co and published on the Fairlane Finance website. The views, opinions and conclusions expressed are those of the contributor alone, not statements of Fairlane Finance’s position. Publication does not constitute Fairlane Finance’s endorsement of the contributor’s views, services or any proposed acquisition.


The material is general information only. It is not financial, credit, investment, legal, tax, accounting, compliance or valuation advice, and does not take account of your objectives, financial position or circumstances. Do not rely on it as a substitute for independent investigation and advice from appropriately qualified professionals. You are responsible for assessing its accuracy, currency and suitability. Any reliance on it or action taken is at your own risk. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Fairlane Finance disclaims liability for loss or damage arising from reliance on this contributor content. Nothing in this disclaimer excludes or limits rights or liabilities that cannot lawfully be excluded or limited.

bottom of page